You are viewing limited content. For full access, please sign in.

Question

Question

v12 max threshold for Forms submittals?

asked 5 hours ago • Show version history

We have had our Forms server crash once an lock up twice when users all submit approx. 225 forms within 2 hours. I watched it happen this last Monday. 

The scenario is this: (educational sector) Monday is an early release day where teachers submit many of the same form for multiple students. This happens across a large school district. 

This is happening on a Forms server that will not play nice with Chromium so Edge must be used to convert the forms to a PDF to send via email. That is another story but full uninstall and reinstall did not solve the problem.

What I saw first hand in Task Manager was that Edge did not release after the instance had completed. There were 2 or 3 times more "msedge.exe" showing on the details tab then there were instances "In Progress". I watched the save to repository step climb from less than a minute up to 25 minutes. That set the send Email step snowballing up to 10 minutes wait time. There were only 20 in process, but that increased as things did not move. This was a sign of the stress the server was undergoing. Every user felt that. Forms crept to a halt for blocks of 15 to 20 minutes. 

We saw similar behavior on v12 where it held onto data when saving as a TIF (before the bugfix), so this seems like a viable possibility to me. 

The server is a VM with 4 cores and 12GB of RAM. 

What is the expected breaking point? We could throw more cores at it but that would just mask the bug if that's what it is. 2 weeks ago the server actually crashed and rebooted. 

Has anyone else witnessed 200+ forms go through in less than 2 hours and it was ok? 

Thanks in advance for the feedback! 

 

0 0

Replies

replied 3 hours ago

Hello, this is us! It's slowing down processes significantly and a lot of the time not displaying a suspended notification so we're not able to determine the exact task or process it's stuck at. 

1 0
replied 2 hours ago • Show version history

We have some pretty high-volume Forms processes; the software can handle it, but you might be running into resource bottlenecks during traffic spikes; bottlenecks could be on the web server and/or the database server, so keep both in mind.

We're still in the process up upgrading to 12, but we're running 32GB and 12 cores on the Forms server, and the DB server has 64GB with 16 cores (though, it's not the only db on that server). For context, during business hours we have around 250 internal users in the system completing tasks, with about 3000 in progress instances at any given moment.

The challenge is giving the servers enough resources that they don't choke during a spike in activity without wasting too much under average load.

Internal users will have a big impact too. For example, 200 submissions in the middle of the workday hits it a lot harder if you also have a bunch of users actively working in the system, particularly if they use any heavy reports.

Hard to say if the lingering Edge instances from the PDF generation are part of the problem or a result of it, but I'd start with looking for resource bottlenecks on the web and db servers first.

1 0
You are not allowed to follow up in this post.

Sign in to reply to this post.